Spared or Spoiled Film Reviews: Inherent Vice

The rules are simple. The good get spared. The bad get spoiled.

Inherent Vice (Warner Bros. Pictures)

Inherent Vice Poster

Directed by Paul Thomas Anderson

Written by Paul Thomas Anderson  Based on Inherent Vice by Thomas Pynchon

Starring Joaquin PhoenixJosh BrolinOwen WilsonKatherine WaterstonReese WitherspoonBenicio del ToroJena Malone & Joanna Newsom

Inherent Vice, based on the novel by Thomas Pynchon, is a good story. But an overly complicated detective story with too many characters for the screen. It features an amazing cast and I usually like Paul Thomas Anderson but here he’s long-winded and tries too hard to bring that dime store detective novel feel to the screen. Most of the movie is conversations, one after another, like those 50’s detective stories, but this is set in the early 70’s. So, it’s more of a hippie private detective story. Also, there isn’t a single scene in the movie where someone isn’t doing some drug or another. I love the era. I especially love women’s fashion and make-up from that era; mini skirts and long lashes but there was too much drug use back then… apparently. There are moments in the film that are pretty fantastic but they are few and far between. In the meantime there’s too many characters and too much dope and too much talking. It nearly put me to sleep..

Verdict: SPOILED

Josh Brolin and Joaquin Phoenix


I wanted to like Inherent Vice. But I did not. It reminded me, at times, of Mickey Spillane’s Kiss Me Deadly from 1955, just not as good. And with this type of film you usually get the detective as the narrator. But Inherent Vice makes that narrator a third person with an impossibly god’s eye view, she really shouldn’t have because she’s not there.

Joaquin Phoenix

The whole movie just didn’t work because of the narration. But the performances are great. Some of the more zany elements are fun. And like I said there were some cool scenes and a nice story. I probably would have loved the book. So once again, I should have read the book before the movie. I’m not a fan of doing it the other way around.

Inherent Vice

Paul Thomas Anderson’s Inherent Vice doesn’t work as a movie. First it’s too long. And because our hero handles three cases at once, there are too many characters. Too much narration from the third-party and too much drug use. But what really failed for me was the pacing. Inherent Vice almost put me to sleep. It’s atmospheric and laid back, like the 70’s.

Katherine Waterston

Josh Brolin is a highlight however. He plays a crazy police detective who is constantly harassing, abusing and arresting Joaquin’s oft-stoned private eye. Brolin’s character is a real loose cannon. But he’s just so weird and very funny. Benicio del Toro, Reese Witherspoon and Jena Malone are all pretty good too. But Joaquin Phoenix as always wears his character like a suit. I’m starting to think he enjoys playing these wacky people because he likes inhabiting them 24/7.

Martin Short

But anyway, the mystery is interesting, if you can keep your eyes open. The performances are fun, including Martin Short as a heavy drug using, lecherous dentist. It’s just long, long-winded and complicated. I nearly fell asleep a bunch of times. There is however, at the end, a satisfying and exciting climax, if you can keep your eyes open that long, where our hero solves his cases like a champ and even gets the girl. Inherent Vice just needed to be about 30 minutes shorter and narrated by the P.I. himself.

Long-winded and boring.

– Mel


One thought on “Spared or Spoiled Film Reviews: Inherent Vice

  1. I agree completely up to the point where you dissed Les Miserable. But about Inherent Vice we are in perfect agreement. I obviously stuck around for the ending but it was touch and go there for awhile.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s